Bob Dylan’s Nobel Prize Isn’t About Music – The Atlantic
The Swedish Academyâs official bibliography for Bob Dylan, recipient of the 2016 Nobel Prize in Literature, begins with the category âWorks in English.â The first listed entry is the Bob Dylan Song Book, a 1965 collection of sheet music and lyrics, and the last is If Not For You, a little-noticed 2016 childrenâs book that that illustrated the lyrics of a 1970 Dylan song. His self-repudiated 1971 prose collection Tarantula and 2004 memoir Chronicles, Volume One are in there, too.
So âworks,â in this context, means books. Theyâre listed before the albums that provided the lyrics that make up many of those Dylan booksâthe albums whose music, in the Nobel Committeeâs word, gave Dylan âthe status of an icon.â
Handwringing about âwhat is literature?â seems inevitable after the announcement that a rock star has taken the global writing communityâs biggest award. But no great existential crisis is needed. The Nobel Committee could have decided that with this prize it wanted to expand the definition of âliteratureâ to include recorded music, a hugely influential and relatively young art form that doesnât have an award of Nobel-like prestige dedicated to it. But it seems to have declined to do so. Dylan is winning 8 million kronor ($932,786) for his words as they are written and not sungâaffording him a wild degree of praise for something that is not the main achievement of his career.
After this morningâs announcement, an interviewer put to the Nobel Permanent Secretary Sara Danius the notion that because Dylan isnât known for novels or traditional poetry, the committee has âwidened the horizonâ of the literature prize. Darius pushed back:
Well, it may look that way. But really, we havenât, in a way. If you look back, far back, 2,500 years or so ago, you discover Homer and Sappho. And they wrote poetic texts that were meant to be listened to, they were meant to be performed, often together with instruments. Itâs the same way with Bob Dylan. But we still read Homer and Sappho and we enjoy it. And same thing with Bob Dylan. He can be read and should be read, and is a great poet in the grand English poetic tradition.
âHe can be read and should be read.â With those words, Darius is advocating for people to turn off their speakers and pick up a copy of Bob Dylanâs Lyrics tomes, complete collections of his words that have come out in various editions since 1985. She also mentioned that people may want to listen to Blonde on Blonde as an entrypoint. But listening is not what this award is about.